That's what I thought too - but didn't the water turn murky after Jacob died? Plus, she said she was taken there after she'd already killed off some of the Other Others so my bet is she was already CrazyJungle!Claire...but I could be wrong.

I wonder though, if there's a tie-in to the first season's crazy fortune teller telling her that no one else should be allowed to raise her child and the whole "you must go to the island" thing - I wonder why, since she's not a 'candidate'? Maybe she was destined to go to meet Charlie, etc.

Gah, so confusing. I need to sleep on this.

(Poor Sayid - "I am a bad man." Indeed!)